
Naples Beach Club
Best for travelers who want a full-service luxury resort with an extensive spa, multiple dining venues, and family programming.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Naples Beach Club, A Four Seasons Resort is a refined, full-service Gulf-front resort in Old Naples with family programming and a large spa—best for travelers seeking luxury and a wide range of amenities. DiamondHead Beach Resort is a casual beachfront resort on Fort Myers Beach with kitchenette-style rooms and on-site beach dining—best for travelers wanting a straightforward beachfront stay on the Fort Myers Beach strip.
Updated · about 40–45 miles apart

Best for travelers who want a full-service luxury resort with an extensive spa, multiple dining venues, and family programming.

Best for travelers who want direct beachfront access in Fort Myers Beach with simple suite-style rooms and beachfront dining at a mid-range price point.
When Naples Beach Club wins: choose Naples Beach Club if you want a high-end Four Seasons experience—private beach frontage, a large multi-level spa (The Sanctuary), two main resort pools plus a rooftop lap pool, organized kids' and teen programming, and several distinct on-site restaurants and event spaces.
When DiamondHead Beach Resort wins: choose DiamondHead if you want a beachfront property on Fort Myers Beach with kitchenette-equipped rooms, an on-site beachfront restaurant and pool facilities, and straightforward resort amenities at a more casual price point.
Bottom line: Naples Beach Club is the pick for travelers prioritizing luxury services, spa and family programming, and a curated Four Seasons resort experience; DiamondHead Beach Resort is a solid, more casual beachfront option for guests focused on easy beach access and suite-style rooms on Fort Myers Beach.
| Category | Naples Beach Club | DiamondHead Beach Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Five-star Four Seasons luxury, refined coastal service | Casual, family-friendly beachfront resort |
| Location | Old Naples on the Gulf with private beach frontage and walkable access to 5th Avenue South | Fort Myers Beach beachfront on Estero Boulevard |
| Size | Larger resort with many venues and 35,231 sq ft event space (phased opening of some amenities) | 124 guestrooms |
| Audience / age policy | All ages; primary registered guest must be 18+; kids' and teen programming | All ages; not adults-only (no age restriction published) |
| Pools | Two main resort pools plus a 75-foot rooftop lap pool at The Sanctuary (three total) | One outdoor pool and two hot tubs |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues: The Merchant Room (brasserie), HB's (beachfront seafood), Sunset Bar, Naples Trading Company, plus planned Wager | Cōste Island Cuisine beachfront restaurant, poolside bar, room service (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | The Sanctuary — 30,000 sq ft, multi-level spa with thermal/aquatherapy circuit and specialty features | Not published |
| Rooms — signature types | Range of suites and rooms (e.g., Studio Suite, Suite, Oceanfront Suite, 3-bedroom residences) — 18 room types listed | Suite- and room-focused names (e.g., Gulf View Suite, Beach Front Suite, Pool View Suite) |
| Beach | Private white-sand Gulf frontage (roughly 1,000 ft of beach); beach loungers/umbrellas included via resort fee | On the beach at Estero Boulevard with beach sun loungers and towels |
| Parking & transport notes | Valet parking only (no public/self-parking); property on an island reached by boat or ferry — no road access to the resort | Free self parking on site; preferred airport RSW ~20.5 mi |
Naples Beach Club sits on Gulf Shore Boulevard in Old Naples with private beach frontage and easy access to downtown Naples attractions.
Choose Naples Beach Club for proximity to Old Naples dining and a higher-end Gulf experience; note boat/ferry access requirements.
DiamondHead Beach Resort is located directly on Estero Boulevard in Fort Myers Beach, steps from the sand.
Choose DiamondHead for a straightforward Fort Myers Beach location with walk-out beach access and local strip atmosphere.
Naples Beach Club offers a wide range of rooms and suites including oceanfront and multi-bedroom residences.
Choose Naples Beach Club for more luxury suite options and larger multi-bedroom residences.
DiamondHead’s 124 guestrooms are primarily suite-style, many with kitchenettes and private balconies.
Choose DiamondHead if you want kitchenette-equipped suites and simple in-room conveniences on the beach.
Naples Beach Club offers multiple curated dining venues, from a brasserie overseen by a notable chef to beachfront seafood.
Choose Naples Beach Club for a wider, more refined dining program and multiple on-site concepts.
DiamondHead has a beachfront restaurant and a poolside bar serving American cuisine and drinks.
Choose DiamondHead for simple, convenient beachfront dining without extensive fine-dining options.
Naples Beach Club operates multiple pool environments plus a rooftop lap pool at its Sanctuary spa.
Choose Naples Beach Club for multiple pool environments that suit families and adults separately.
DiamondHead offers a single outdoor pool and two hot tubs alongside direct beach access.
Choose DiamondHead for a straightforward beachfront pool area and easy sand access.
Naples Beach Club centers wellness at The Sanctuary and offers on-site fitness, tennis, and planned recreational additions.
Choose Naples Beach Club if you prioritize spa and structured wellness plus on-site sports and family activities.
DiamondHead’s offerings focus on beach and simple on-site recreation.
Choose DiamondHead for beach-centered leisure and basic activity options; spa services are not published.

Naples Beach Club — The Sanctuary is a large, multi-level spa with a thermal circuit and specialty treatments.

DiamondHead Beach Resort — direct beachfront location on Estero Boulevard with easy beach and pool access.

Naples Beach Club — Kids For All Seasons plus teen programming and separate family-friendly pool spaces.

DiamondHead Beach Resort — many room types include kitchenettes and private balconies for convenient longer stays.
Naples Beach Club — it has The Sanctuary spa (30,000 sq ft) with a thermal circuit and specialty treatments; DiamondHead does not publish a full-service spa.
Both properties have beach access, but DiamondHead sits directly on Fort Myers Beach while Naples Beach Club provides private Gulf frontage in Old Naples.
No. Both properties are all-ages resorts; Naples Beach Club has structured kids' and teen programming and requires the primary registered guest to be at least 18.
Naples Beach Club has multiple distinct dining venues (brasserie, beachfront seafood, bar, café) while DiamondHead lists one beachfront restaurant and a poolside bar.
Explore how Naples Beach Club stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·