
Naples Beach Club
Best for travelers who want direct private beach access, multiple pools, a large full-service spa, and family programming on-site.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Naples Beach Club is a beachfront, full-service Four Seasons resort with multiple pools, a large spa, family programming, and private Gulf access — good for travelers who want a luxury beach-first stay with resort amenities. Inn on Fifth is an upscale downtown boutique hotel on Fifth Avenue South that suits travelers who prioritize immediate access to dining, shopping, and a compact, walkable Old Naples experience.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want direct private beach access, multiple pools, a large full-service spa, and family programming on-site.

Best for travelers who want to stay steps from Fifth Avenue South restaurants and shops in a compact, upscale downtown hotel.
When Naples Beach Club wins: Choose Naples Beach Club if your priority is a beachfront setting, resort-scale pools and spa facilities (The Sanctuary), family programming, and multiple on-site dining venues. The resort experience and private Gulf access are the main draws.
When Inn on Fifth wins: Choose Inn on Fifth if you want to be in the middle of Old Naples’ dining and shopping on Fifth Avenue South and prefer a smaller, downtown boutique hotel with quick pedestrian access to restaurants and local attractions.
Bottom line: Pick Naples Beach Club for a full-scale beachfront Four Seasons resort experience centered on sand, pools, and wellness; pick Inn on Fifth for a compact, convenient Old Naples base focused on walkable dining and shopping.
| Category | Naples Beach Club | Inn on Fifth |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Beachfront luxury resort with large-spa, family and couples programming. | Upscale downtown boutique hotel focused on dining and shopping access. |
| Location | On the Gulf with direct private beach access (801/851 Gulf Shore Blvd N). | On Fifth Avenue South in Old Naples (699 5th Ave S), steps from shops and restaurants. |
| Size / Rooms | Room types: 18 named room/suite types (exact room count not published). | 119 guestrooms. |
| Ages / audience | Family-oriented resort; children’s club and teen centre available; primary guest must be 18+ to check in. | All-ages boutique hotel; not adults-only; standard hotel policies apply. |
| Pools & beach | Three pool spaces (two main resort pools + Sanctuary rooftop lap pool) and private Gulf beach access with loungers/umbrellas. | One outdoor pool and a hot tub; complimentary beach shuttle to Naples Beach. |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues (The Merchant Room, HB’s, Sunset Bar, Naples Trading Company, plus The Wager planned). | One restaurant and a bar/lounge, plus poolside bar and in-room service (limited hours). |
| Spa & wellness | The Sanctuary: 30,000 sq. ft., multi-level spa with 13+ treatment rooms, thermal/aquatherapy circuit and signature Ammortal Chamber. | Full-service spa offering massages, facials, and body treatments; reservations required. |
| Event & meeting space | Extensive event facilities including large ballrooms and outdoor terraces (total ~35,231 sq ft). | Conference space and meeting rooms for business and events. |
| Accessibility & services | Wheelchair-accessible paths, pools, spa; valet parking only; complimentary on-property electric MOKEs and bike rentals. | Wheelchair-accessible (may have limitations), 24-hour front desk, business center, valet (surcharge). |
| Nearby draw | Private white-sand Gulf beach and resort grounds; close access to Old Naples attractions via resort transport. | Steps from Fifth Avenue South, Cambier Park, and walking access to parts of the waterfront. |
Naples Beach Club sits on roughly 1,000 feet of private Gulf shoreline and fronts a private beach.
Choose Naples Beach Club for an on-site Gulf beach experience and resort grounds.
Inn on Fifth sits on Fifth Avenue South in the heart of Old Naples’ dining and shopping district.
Choose Inn on Fifth if being steps from Fifth Avenue South’s restaurants and shops is the priority.
Naples Beach Club offers a range of room types and multi-room residences designed for families and couples.
Pick the resort for larger suite/residence options and family-friendly room configurations.
Inn on Fifth provides traditional hotel guestrooms and suites in a boutique downtown property.
Pick Inn on Fifth for a compact, comfortable downtown room with convenient access to shops and restaurants.
Naples Beach Club runs several venue types from a fine-dining brasserie to a beachfront seafood restaurant and beach bar.
Choose the resort if you want several on-site dining options and beachfront meals without leaving the property.
Inn on Fifth has a single main restaurant plus bar/lounge and limited room service hours.
Choose Inn on Fifth if you plan to dine out on Fifth Avenue and want quick pedestrian access to many local restaurants.
Naples Beach Club emphasizes its aquatic offerings: multiple pools plus private beach frontage.
The resort is the clear choice for guests who want on-site beach and multiple pool experiences.
Inn on Fifth has a single outdoor pool and hot tub; beach access is via a complimentary shuttle.
Choose Inn on Fifth if you value downtown location and will use the beach shuttle or local beaches rather than on-site beachfront amenities.
Naples Beach Club centers wellness around The Sanctuary spa plus broad activity options.
Pick Naples Beach Club for a comprehensive wellness program and resort recreation options.
Inn on Fifth offers a full-service spa and easy access to Old Naples nightlife on Fifth Avenue South.
Choose Inn on Fifth if you prefer short strolls to downtown nightlife and a compact hotel spa.

Private Gulf beach access plus multiple pool options (including rooftop lap pool) make Naples Beach Club the choice for beach-focused stays.

The Sanctuary’s large thermal circuit, treatment rooms, and signature features prioritize resort-scale wellness.

Inn on Fifth places you steps from Fifth Avenue South restaurants, boutiques, and Cambier Park.

Inn on Fifth’s boutique scale and location suit travelers who want a short, walkable stay with quick access to Old Naples attractions.
Naples Beach Club — it has dedicated kids’ and teen programming, family-friendly pool areas, and suite/residence options; Inn on Fifth is all-ages but oriented to downtown stays rather than a full family-resort program.
Yes — Inn on Fifth is about 1 km from Naples Beach and offers a complimentary beach shuttle; it is not beachfront.
Naples Beach Club — The Sanctuary is a 30,000 sq. ft., multi-level spa with thermal and aquatherapy features; Inn on Fifth has a full-service spa but on a much smaller scale.
Yes — both properties list wheelchair-accessible features, though Inn on Fifth notes potential limitations in some accessibility details.
Explore how Naples Beach Club stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·