
Naples Beach Club
Best for travelers who want upscale, spa-forward beachfront accommodations with formal dining and family programming.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Naples Beach Club is a polished Four Seasons beachfront resort offering full-service luxury, family programming, and an extensive spa — read this if you want refined Gulf-coast luxury and on-site wellness. Margaritaville Beach Resort Fort Myers is a branded, lifestyle beachfront resort in Fort Myers Beach with casual dining, multiple bars, and active public spaces — read this if you want a laid-back, social beach stay with recognizable branding.
Updated

Best for travelers who want upscale, spa-forward beachfront accommodations with formal dining and family programming.

Best for travelers who want a casual, branded beach-resort vibe with multiple dining outlets, bars, and more budget-friendly beachfront access.
When Naples Beach Club wins: choose Naples Beach Club for elevated dining (The Merchant Room, HB's), a large, multi-level Sanctuary spa experience, curated family programming, and a more refined, luxury resort operation run by Four Seasons.
When Margaritaville Beach Resort Fort Myers wins: choose Margaritaville for a more relaxed, tropical-branded stay on Fort Myers Beach with multiple bars and restaurants on-site, easy beach access, larger room inventory, and generally lower-key service that suits casual beach vacations.
Bottom line: pick Naples Beach Club when you want Four Seasons–level luxury, signature spa facilities, and formal dining; pick Margaritaville Beach Resort Fort Myers when you want a fun, social beachfront resort with many on-property dining and bar options and a more casual price point.
| Category | Naples Beach Club | Margaritaville Beach Resort Fort Myers |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Polished, full-service luxury and curated wellness | Laid-back, tropical lifestyle resort with lively public spaces |
| Location | Old Naples on private Gulf-facing beach within a 125-acre beachfront community (island access rules apply) | Fort Myers Beach — on the beach at 251 Crescent Street |
| Size (rooms) | 18 room types; mix of rooms, suites and multi-bedroom residences | 254 air-conditioned rooms across many standard and accessible room types |
| Ages / audience | All-ages resort with dedicated kids' and teen programming (Kids For All Seasons) | All ages — family-friendly; not adults-only |
| Pools | Two main resort pools plus a rooftop lap pool at The Sanctuary spa (three total) | One outdoor pool; pool cabanas available (surcharge) |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple signature venues: The Merchant Room (brasserie), HB's (beachfront seafood), Sunset Bar, Naples Trading Company; more venues opening in phases | Four restaurants, a coffee shop/cafe, a beach bar and four bars/lounges |
| Spa & wellness | The Sanctuary — 30,000 sq ft, multi-level spa with thermal/aquatherapy circuit and signature treatments | Full-service spa offering massages and typical resort spa treatments |
| Known for | High-end service, extensive spa thermal circuit, refined dining and family programming | Branded beachfront vibe, lively bars and casual dining, recognizable Margaritaville theming |
| Resort fee / mandatory charges | Mandatory resort fee reported (example amount USD 83.25/night on some listings) | Mandatory resort fee reported (USD 50.18 per accommodation, per night) |
| Accessibility & policies | Wheelchair-accessible facilities and family policies; minimum check-in age 18 | Wheelchair accessible (some limitations); check-in minimum age listed as 21 |
| Parking | Valet parking only (fee) and on-property shuttle (MOKEs) for local transport | Valet parking available (surcharge) |
Naples Beach Club sits on roughly 1,000 feet of private Gulf shoreline in Old Naples as part of a large beachfront community.
Choose Naples Beach Club for proximity to Old Naples shopping and a quiet, refined beachfront setting.
Margaritaville Beach Resort Fort Myers sits on Fort Myers Beach with direct beach frontage at 251 Crescent Street.
Choose Margaritaville for an unmistakably casual, social beach location on Fort Myers Beach.
Naples Beach Club offers a mix of spacious rooms, suites and multi-bedroom residences across 18 named room types.
Choose Naples Beach Club when you need larger suites, residences, or a more varied luxury room inventory.
Margaritaville Beach Resort Fort Myers lists 254 air-conditioned rooms across a broad range of standard and accessible room types.
Choose Margaritaville for straightforward, comfortable rooms with many accessible options and easy beachfront views on select room types.
Naples Beach Club focuses on refined coastal dining and several distinct venues.
Pick Naples Beach Club for elevated dining, formal brasserie meals, and a quieter evening atmosphere.
Margaritaville centers around casual, themed dining with multiple bars and outlets.
Pick Margaritaville for variety of casual dining and easy bar-hopping on property.
Naples Beach Club operates several pool spaces and direct beach access.
Choose Naples Beach Club for multiple pool atmospheres plus direct private beach access and a dedicated rooftop lap pool.
Margaritaville has a single outdoor pool and direct beach frontage.
Choose Margaritaville for a straightforward pool and beach setup focused on casual beach time.
Naples Beach Club places a strong emphasis on wellness and curated leisure.
Choose Naples Beach Club for a wellness-forward stay and quieter evening scene with refined dining and live-music options.
Margaritaville offers basic spa services plus lively evening social spaces.
Choose Margaritaville for casual nightlife centered on bars, outdoor spaces and an informal social scene.

The Sanctuary at Naples Beach Club offers a large, multi-level thermal circuit and curated signature treatments.

Margaritaville’s multiple bars, beach bar and casual restaurants make it easy to socialize without leaving the property.

Naples Beach Club’s Merchant Room and HB's provide elevated coastal and brasserie dining options.

Margaritaville provides a recognizable lifestyle brand with many on-site dining choices and straightforward rooms.
Naples Beach Club is explicitly set up for families with dedicated kids' and teen programming; Margaritaville is family-friendly too but focuses more on casual beach and bar areas.
Naples Beach Club’s Sanctuary is a large, multi-level 30,000 sq ft spa with a thermal circuit; Margaritaville offers a full-service spa but on a smaller scale.
No. Margaritaville Beach Resort Fort Myers is not adults-only.
Yes. Both properties offer direct beach access on the Gulf, though they are in different towns.
Explore how Naples Beach Club stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·